Welcome to The GIST’s Sunday Scroll, where we dive deep into one timely sports topic.
- So today, we’re highlighting some of the most memorable comeback performances in sports history. Enjoy!
QUOTE OF THE DAY
"I almost never, ever, ever give up, but at that point, I kind of did give up."
— Barb Beebe, mother of former Buffalo Bills wide receiver Don Beebe, talking about the 1992–93 AFC Wild Card game before the comeback. Read on to see why you really can’t blame her.
🏈 “The Comeback”
You can’t start a newsletter about comebacks without the game literally called “The Comeback.” The year was 1993. It was a blustery January day in Orchard Park, New York. And the home team, the Buffalo Bills, was down 32 points to the visiting Houston Oilers early in the third quarter of the AFC Wild Card game.
- The teams had faced each other in the final regular-season game just a week earlier, where Bills star quarterback (QB) Jim Kelly had suffered a knee injury, leaving backup QB Frank Reich to start his first-ever playoff game.
Led by five-time Grey Cup champ QB Warren Moon, Houston dominated early, leading 28–3 at the half. In the locker room, Bills head coach Marv Levy and defensive coordinator Walt Corey made impassioned pleas to their team. As wide receiver Steve Tasker later described, Levy “appealed to our pride. It wound up working.”
- The Bills scored 35 points to the Oilers' 10 in the second half, to send the game into overtime (OT). In OT, Houston’s Moon threw an interception on the first drive, and the Oilers were dealt a controversial penalty in the subsequent play.
- Buffalo then made a 32-yard field goal (FG) to give the Bills the 41–38 win. To this day, it remains the largest comeback in NFL history.
🎓🏈 College comebacks
Before leading the Bills to history, the aforementioned Frank Reich played backup QB for the NCAA Div I Maryland Terrapins. After starter Stan Gelbaugh failed to lead a scoring drive in the first half of a 1984 game, Reich replaced him against the defending national champion Miami Hurricanes.
- Down 31–0 at the half, Reich led five scoring drives in the second half, giving the “Terps” a seemingly impossible 42–40 win to mark the biggest comeback in college football history at the time. What can we say? The man loves a comeback.
That record stood until 2006, when Northwestern took a 38–3 lead over Michigan State with 9:54 left in the third quarter. Neither team was particularly good that season, so no one predicted that this relatively low-key regular-season game would end up in the record books.
- WIth a quarter and a half left in the game, Michigan State scored five unanswered TDs to tie the game before making a FG with 18 seconds remaining to win 41–38. It still remains the largest college football comeback.
🏈 Super Bowl LI
Of course QB Tom Brady is somehow involved. By February 2017, Brady and his then-New England Patriots had already racked up four Super Bowls, and he was making his record seventh Super Bowl appearance (he’s broken that record three times since), this time against the Atlanta Falcons in Super Bowl LI.
Halfway through the third quarter, the Falcons had a 28–3 lead, and ESPN estimated their odds of winning the game to be 99.8%. And then the unimaginable happened. With three unanswered TDs from Brady et al. plus a FG, the Pats tied up the game in the final minute to force OT.
- A short TD run from RB James White ultimately gave the Pats the win — and the Lombardi Trophy — in the largest comeback win in Super Bowl history and third-largest in NFL playoff history.
🏃♀️ Olympic comeback
At the Tokyo Olympics this summer, Dutch runner Sifan Hassan won gold in the 5,000m and 10,000m and bronze in the 1,500m, becoming the only athlete ever to medal in all three events at the same Olympic Games. But to get there, she mounted a comeback that you had to see to believe.
During a heat for the 1,500m, Hassan tangled up with Kenyan runner Edinah Jebitok at the start of the last lap. Despite fully falling onto the track, Hassan picked herself up, rejoined the pack of racers who had pulled ahead of her, and then passed them to win the heat. Down but never out.
⚾️ The Curse
The Curse of the Bambino began in 1920, when the Boston Red Sox sold baseball legend Babe Ruth to the New York Yankees. The Red Sox had last won the World Series in 1918 with Ruth, and despite some success over the decades after he left, the team was never able to win another championship...until 2004.
The Red Sox faced the Yankees in the best-of-seven American League Championship Series (ALCS) that year, in a rematch of the previous season’s ALCS (won by the Yankees). The Red Sox seemed to be dealt a similar fate, going down three games to start the series.
- Down 4–3 in the ninth inning of Game 4, on the verge of elimination, Red Sox outfielder Dave Roberts stole second and then scored to force extra innings, leading to a 6–4 win for Boston after 12 innings.
And Boston never looked back. The Red Sox won the next three games, marking the only time in MLB playoff history that a 3-0 series lead was erased. The icing on the cake? Boston went on to win the World Series, ending the 86-year championship drought and The Curse.
⛳️ Miracle at Medinah
The comeback that inspired us today. The Ryder Cup is a rare team competition in the solitary game of golf. Twelve Americans and 12 Europeans face off every two years to win literally nothing but a small trophy and eternal bragging rights.
- Originally, the Ryder Cup was a competition between the USA and Great Britain, but in 1979, young Spanish golfers Seve Ballesteros and Antonio Garrido became the first non-British Europeans to be included.
- The addition made all the difference, with Ballesteros becoming one of the most prolific golfers in history and leading Europe to five Ryder Cup wins as both a player and a captain.
Ballesteros died in 2011, a year before his best friend and Ryder Cup teammate José María Olazábal captained Team Europe in the 2012 Ryder Cup at the Medinah Country Club. That Ryder Cup got off to a rough start for the Europeans, and by the end of Day 2 in the three-day event, Europe was down a seemingly insurmountable four points.
- Wearing Ballesteros’ traditional Sunday colors — navy blue and white — and with an outline of the icon on their golf bags, Europe needed eight of the available 12 points on the final day.
They won eight and a half points. Though some Americans still refer to it as the “Meltdown at Medinah,” golf fans from both sides of the Atlantic agree that the “Miracle at Medinah” was indeed a European comeback for the ages, inspired by their fearless leader Olazábal and dedicated to his friend Seve.
- For more Ryder Cup action, don’t miss the final singles matches of the 2020 Ryder Cup today (yes, we’re still doing that weird 2020 stuff), with coverage on NBC in the U.S. and TSN in Canada, starting at noon ET.